Annuity Rates, Annuities, Pensions, Divorce Annuity Rates Charts
Home News Annuity Rates Annuities Pension Annuity Impaired Annuity Annuity Quotes Pensions Divorce Resources

28 October 2016 last updated

Scrapped pension annuity sales market would have been poor value

The plan by the government to allow people to sell their annuities for cash would result in poor value due to the risk to buyers arriving at a price for the annuity and potential for fraud against consumers.

Last month the government scrapped George Osborne's second hand pension annuity market intended to allow people to sell their annuity for a lump sum.

The Treasury came to this decision after consulting the pensions industry, regulators and consumer groups saying that although there would be enough people willing to sell their annuity there were not enough buyers to to make a competitive market.

The plan was proposed following the pension freedoms in the March 2015 budget to create more freedom for the 5 million people with annuities and for those that would buy them in the future.

In addition the Treasury believed the second hand annuity market could not be balanced with sufficient consumer protection resulting in poor consumer outcomes.

Second hand annuity market scraped
  The second hand market for pension annuities would have offered poor value to consumers
  More annuity topics
  Quarter 4 News 2016
  News & articles
  Archive news stories
  Flexi-access drawdown
  Annuity rates tables
  Outlook for 2019
  Annuity rates charts
  15-year gilt yields
  Latest annuity rates

Lack of support from providers

The proposed second hand annuity market suffered from a lack of support from providers with Standard Life in February 2016 opting not to take part.

In order to work there would need to be an active market of insurance companies buying back their own annuities and sufficient numbers of other buyers competing to buy on the open market. In the end very few companies were willing to support the plan with only Legal & General and Just Retirement open to the idea.

There were also a number of uncertainties in the second hand market for the buyer. Firstly how would they calculate the value for the lump sum for the annuity and this could be the original fund less income paid and costs plus tax paid to date. It could mean a fund of £100,000 after three years would reduce to £75,000.

In addition when the annuity was bought part of the income would have benefited from a mortality cross-subsidy. This is where some of the annuitants die earlier than expected and part of their fund is added back which helps to increase the annuity rates for other annuitants.

If an annuitant leaves an insurance company would underwrite them for any medical conditions which would mean an even lower fund value would be offered.

Risks to the consumer

The difficulty calculating the fund value from a buyer and possible high costs associated with the offer could mean people despite for the cash sum would receive a poor outcome.

From the point of view of HM Treasury, it was clear that "creating the conditions to allow a vibrant and competitive market to emerge with multiple buyers and sellers of pension annuities could not be balanced with sufficient consumer protection".

The Treasury further said "Consumer protection is a top priority for the government, and we are not willing to allow a market to develop which could produce poor outcomes for consumers, such as receiving poor value for their annuity income stream and suffering higher costs".

Simon Kirby, the Treasury economic secretary, said: “It has become clear that we cannot guarantee consumers will get good value for money in a market that is likely to be small and limited. Pursuing this policy in these circumstances would put consumers at risk – this is something I am not prepared to do.”

Related internet links:
Guardian - Treasury makes U-turn on second hand market
Citywire - Government abandons annuity sellers market
Annuity Rates
  Age Single Joint  
  55 £3,947 £3,702  
  60 £4,391 £4,052  
  65 £5,098 £4,638  
  70 £6,055 £5,457  
£100,000 purchase, level rates, standard
Unisex rates and joint life basis
  Annuity Rates  
Annuity Quotes
  Plan your annuity and get quotes from the 12 leading providers  
  free annuity quote Free Annuity Quotes
  annuity quote no obligation No Obligation
  annuity quote all providers From All Providers
  Annuity Quote  
  Annuity Rates News:

Gilt yields rise with US-China trade deal
Gilt yields rise with US-China trade deal

15-year gilt yields rise 14 basis points with annuity rates up for the second month

Providers increase annuity rates by 5%
Providers increase annuity rates Standard annuities rise over 5% with gilt yields recovering from all time lows
Cash annuity offer 14% more income
Purchased life annuity better value Purchased life annuities offer 14% more income than pension annuity
Impaired annuities rise with higher yields
Impaired annuities up 1.5% Impaired annuity rates from providers rise 1.5% with prospect of Brexit deal
Gilt yields rise and Trump delays tariff
Yields recover from all time low

Yields recover from a low as Donald Trump considers limited trade deal with China

  Follow Us:
You can follow the latest annuity updates on Twitter or as a fan on Facebook
  Facebook Page Twitter Page   This website is for marketing purposes only and does not provide specific financial or legal advice. Website security issued by GeoTrust and Equifax. Copyright©2001-20 All Rights Reserved